Every year, millions of people eagerly await the return of one of America’s favorite traditions: Girl Scout Cookie season. These sweet treats have been an integral part of the Girl Scouts organization since 1917 and have evolved into a mouthwatering array of flavors over time. But which cookies reign supreme? Here is a definitive ranking of the absolute best Girl Scout Cookies.

1. Thin Mints

It’s no surprise that Thin Mints hold the top spot in our ranking. These refreshing chocolate and mint cookies are simply irresistible when enjoyed straight from the freezer. Their perfect balance of rich chocolate coating and a crisp, minty center make Thin Mints a top seller every year.

2. Caramel deLites / Samoas

Featuring caramel, chocolate, and coconut, these chewy delights are packed with scrumptious layers of flavor. Caramel deLites, also known as Samoas, boast a satisfying mix of textures with their crunchy base and gooey caramel topping.

3. Peanut Butter Patties / Tagalongs

Peanut butter lovers rejoice! The Peanut Butter Patties, also called Tagalongs, expertly combine a generous layer of peanut butter with a light and crispy cookie, encased in smooth milk chocolate. This trio of flavors earns them the third spot on our list.

4. Trefoils / Shortbread

Returning to the classic roots of cookie baking is the Trefoil or Shortbread cookie. This simple yet scrumptious buttery delight is stamped with the iconic Girl Scout logo and is perfect for those who appreciate a more traditional treat.

5. Do-si-dos / Peanut Butter Sandwich

Another excellent offering for peanut butter enthusiasts are Do-si-dos, also known as Peanut Butter Sandwich cookies. With their crunchy oatmeal cookie exterior and creamy peanut butter filling, these cookies bring both taste and texture to the table.

6. S’mores

A recent addition to the Girl Scout Cookie lineup, the S’mores cookie seamlessly brings the nostalgic flavor of campfire treats to your home. With a delicious graham cracker and marshmallow filling encased in chocolate, these cookies are perfect for savoring whenever you need a taste of summer.

7. Lemonades

For those who prefer a zesty treat, Lemonades offer the perfect sweet and tangy combination. These refreshing, lemon-flavored cookies boast a light and crisp texture that is ideal for enjoying on warm days or whenever you’re craving something bright and cheerful.

8. Toffee-tastic

Toffee-tastic cookies are gluten-free goodies that cater to those with dietary restrictions or those just seeking a delightful toffee treat. While they may not have the same popularity as their other counterparts, these buttery cookies dotted with bits of toffee are sure to satisfy any sweet tooth.

There you have it – a definitive ranking of the absolute best Girl Scout Cookies! Whether you’re grabbing your favorites or trying new flavors during cookie season, these treats are more than just cookies; they’re an annual tradition and fundraiser that showcases the hard work and entrepreneurial spirit of young girls across America.